Promised Land is the latest Matt Damon version of Erin Brakovich….only without the drama of a true story, with some reasonable equivocation over the pros and cons of Fracking. The script was co-written by Damon and John Krazinski and has a few good moments, but mostly stays in the mediocre realm.
Te story is about a team of energy salesmen (Damon and Francis MacDormand) who swoop into a community and buy up Fracking rights from farmers at the lowest possible prices and with the least opposition. Naturally, there’s a retired MIT professor (Hal Holbrook) who takes the opposing side and causes trouble in the community. Unfortunately, the closest we get to life and death drama is a photoshopped picture of some dead cows. Maybe therein lies the real problem, ecological disaster is only poignant enough for a film if its about human life or death.
The twist in this plot comes from Krazinsky, the e illogical agitator. Naturally he’s loved and hated by the town folk, but the viewer is having a hard time thinking of him as anything other than Jim from the Scranton Office.
Fracking is simply too complicated an issue. There is lots to commend energy self-sufficiency even if when done badly it can damage the land. I felt like this story did come through, but there goes the drama with it. Complexity helps books and really good movies, but with weak scripts like this it does nothing but make us all yawn.